Description

THE REAL TEST FOR MUHAMMAD'S PROPHETHOOD
Let's just play the devil's advocate and say Muhammad suffered no immediate ill effects from the Khaybar poisoning because he was a prophet. Granted his prophethood is confirmed and affirmed by that aspect, how about his companions who died? Why did he let them die?
Earlier prophets, true prophets of God were known to perform miracles, just like Elijah and Jesus raised the dead. Considering that Muhammad's companions/disciples ingested large volumes of the poison from the same meal and dropped dead instantly, why didn't Muhammad pray to Allah and raise his dead companions from the instant death and prove all doubters wrong including the Jewish woman who poisoned him for doubting his prophethood?
Muhammad would have proved beyond reasonable doubt that he was a true prophet by raising his companions from the dead and that would have been a bigger confirmation of his prophethood than just surviving poisoning, a fact that can be medically explained by bio-accumulation, the same bio-accumulation that caused his death few years later?
Secondly, imagine during the wedding feast in Cana (John Chapter 2), Peter, John, Matthew, Luke and Mark ingested poison and died instantly, would Jesus have raised them from their deaths, rendered the ingested poison harmless by just touching their tummies or just said, let's go bury them? What would Jesus have done? What would a true prophet of God have done?
Thirdly, Muhammad claimed to have received a revelation about Jews intention to kill him in Medina and preempted that by beheading close to 900 Jewish men to avert the intended assassination. Granted he could receive revelations before events, why didn't he receive revelation about the intended poisoning and avert his and companions demise by ingesting poisoned food?
I rest my case, Muhammad could not perform a miracle to prove his prophethood, his dead companions is the clearest proof for that. Now as a Muhammadan, Muhammad in his lifetime could not help his companions, what makes you think now that he is dead, he will help or intercede for you on Judgement Day?
This is a simple logical question, nothing complicated to require scholars opinion. Straight forward logic. Think just this one time, why couldn't Muhammad help his companions at their hour on need? Muhammad claimed dates cured poison, why couldn't he use the dates to heal his comrades? Muhammad was a liar and an imposter who could not help his nearest and dearest and cannot help you an unknown, now or in the hearafter. Call on Jesus, who even in the present is curing and healing Muhammadan apostates now Christians.